Near-zero ETF fees put index design centre stage

Since its inception 50 years ago, index investing has largely been about making broad market exposure cheap and accessible. Total expense ratio (TER), in turn, became the headline metric in deciding what ETF to buy.   

Fast-forward to today and most standard equity ETFs charge between 0.02% to 0.04% (the so-called core index “floor”). Costs, while still significant, are no longer a key differentiator, and the question for many investors is now “what am I buying?”, not “who is cheapest?”  

Why index design matters: the megacap example 

Megacap concentration illustrates this point clearly. Most broad equity indices are market-cap weighted, so a handful of giant tech stocks now make up a large – possibly concerning – share of their total weight. Take the S&P 500 for example. At the beginning of October 2026, the Magnificent Seven accounted for around 35% of the index.  

An investor could, therefore, own a global equity ETF, a US large-cap fund and a growth product and hold the same top ten positions in all three, exposing them to the very problem they were trying to avoid: portfolio concentration.  

Four ways to differentiate through index design 

Accepting that ETF fees are converging to near zero, differentiation has to come from the quality and clarity of the underlying index. We see four key areas for asset managers to focus on: 

  • Target a specific outcome. How do I limit reliance on certain stocks or sectors, tilt towards quality, or generate sustainable income? The more precisely an index is built around a real investor need, the easier it is to explain, position and choose over a near-identical alternative.  
  • Build rules that manage risk. Rules and techniques like single-stock caps, sector limits and minimum-variance optimisation can help to control concentration, volatility and downside risks.  
  • Provide distinctive exposure. This could be improving upon an established market or an entirely new idea that existing benchmarks don’t capture such as an emerging theme or economy. Overlap, active share and concentration profiles can help demonstrate what an index adds to a portfolio.  
  • Be transparent and investable. Published eligibility, weighting and rebalancing rules let investors understand and replicate how an index behaves. Liquidity screens and capacity limits make sure it works in practice, not just on paper. 

Making index design a competitive advantage 

Good design, however, is only part of the equation. To compete on design, asset managers need to move quickly: backtesting a new index, refining the rules and bringing it to market. Traditionally this process has been slow, manual and expensive, which has kept index design out of reach for many. Modern index technology, however, changes that.  

PANTA’s Index Operating System gives asset managers one platform to design, test, launch and operate indices, making the end-to-end process more efficient. As a result, firms can focus on creating innovative products and strategies rather than the infrastructure behind them.  

The bottom line 

The fee-cutting era delivered real benefits to investors, but it has largely run its course as a source of competitive advantage. As TERs converge towards zero, asset managers will increasingly stand out through design: a clear objective, deliberate risk rules, distinct exposure, and transparent methodology. In short, when cost is a given, index design is what will set products apart. 

Share the Post:

— RELATED INSIGHTS & NEWS

The death of the 60/40 portfolio and the rise of index blending 

Index blending: Building multi-asset exposure from components 

Equal-weighted indices: A hedge against concentration (with trade-offs)